Philly Saw It First

A list of seminal shows that opened in Philadelphia theaters.

Published: Aug 6, 2008

In the days of pre-Broadway tours, Philly was one of the big three cities (along with Boston and New Haven) that got plays and musicals in their tryout period. Here are some shows that opened in a Philadelphia theater — before they hit the Great White Way:

Walnut Street Theatre
  • 'A Streetcar Named Desire' (with the legendary original cast: Marlon Brando, Jessica Tandy)
  • 'A Raisin in the Sun' (Sidney Poitier)
  • 'Mister Roberts' (Henry Fonda)
  • 'Gigi' (the non-musical version starring Audrey Hepburn, who would make her Broadway debut in the role)
  • 'Member of the Wedding' (Julie Harris, Ethel Waters)
  • 'Diary of Anne Frank' (Susan Strasberg, daughter of the famous Lee)
  • 'The Rainmaker' (Geraldine Page)
  • 'Bus Stop' (Kim Stanley, Elaine Stritch)
Merriam Theater (originally the Shubert)
  • By Cole Porter: 'Kiss Me, Kate', 'Out of this World', 'Can Can', 'Silk Stockings
  • By Frank Loesser: 'Guys and Dolls', 'Most Happy Fella', 'Greenwillow', 'How to Succeed in Business
  • By George and Ira Gershwin: 'Funny Face', 'Oh! Kay', 'Girl Crazy', 'Strike Up the Band
  • By Irving Berlin: 'Annie, Get Your Gun
  • By Jule Styne and Stephen Sondheim: 'Gypsy
Forrest Theatre
  • An important house for Rodgers and Hart, including 'Pal Joey', which introduced Gene Kelly as a leading performer and paved the way for "dark" musicals like 'Cabaret 'and 'Chicago'; also the revised 'A Connecticut Yankee', the team's last project together
  • Irving Berlin's 'As Thousands Cheer', a revolutionary revue with songs that included "Supper Time" and "Heat Wave," both introduced by Ethel Waters; also 'Miss Liberty
  • Sondheim's 'Anyone Can Whistle', which would become a famous Broadway failure (12 previews, nine performances, then out) — but a cult favorite. 'Whistle 'was Angela Lansbury's first Broadway musical.

Comments

The list of Philadelphia premieres makes me think of a story Tony Randall told on a talk show decades ago: He was appearing in a play at the Walnut that was dying a slow and painful death in tryouts. Worse, the Christmas Eve performance played to a house that was probably smaller than the cast. When the cast took its bows, one actor called out "Merry Christmas!" And from the house came the response: "GO TO HELL!"
by Liz in exile... on March 27th 2009 9:52 PM



Also In This Week's Cover Story Section

Cover Story:
Alas, Poor Theater
by David Anthony Fox

 
 
ADVERTISEMENT