NEWS . Man Overboard!

No Benefits

Forget the public option — gimme a SEPTA plan.

Published: Nov 4, 2009

Let's talk benefits — and not the friends-with kind. Wachovia has long offered its employees here a good benefit indeed — up to about 40 percent of the cost of tuition at FunKids Knowledge Learning Center, a day care inside the Wachovia building at Fourth and Market. It's great, parents tell me: great location, great teachers, great curriculum — the kind of benefit that just two years ago earned Wachovia the distinction of being a Working Mother magazine top-10 employer. Enter Wells Fargo Co., which took over Wachovia in December 2008 and promptly began cutting benefits — like day care. Parents now face a choice: Pay full tuition, or take their kids elsewhere by Jan. 1. For Wachovia employee Bissett Durham and husband Bill — whose (fortuitously named) son, Isaiah, 4, just started pre-K — it's a real problem. They'd have to pay about $1,000 more a month. "It's not even feasible for us," Bill Durham says.

FunKids will now be open to neighborhood residents. There'll still be kids there come January, but, considering the neighborhood, they'll probably be richer and whiter. Wachovia spokeswoman Barbara Nate says the cuts were about "employee equity" — see, only some bank employees around the country have that benefit, and the bank can't be expected to extend this benefit elsewhere, not in these times. Sure, times are tough. But not, necessarily, for Wells Fargo Co., which accepted some $25 billion in federal bailout money. The bank hasn't paid the money back yet, but it did manage to give raises — technically, increased stock options — to its top four executives this year. CEO John Stumpf now gets a $5.6 million salary. Talk about benefits!

ADVERTISEMENT

Speeeeaking of benefits ... how about that SEPTA strike? Among the demands that Transport Workers Union Local 234 said they just couldn't abide was a hike in their health-insurance contributions — currently 1 percent of their paychecks. One. Whole. Percent. Forget the public option, gimme a SEPTA plan. Why is it, I wonder, that one union can be out there clamoring to keep their amazingly generous health care terms while another, like the scrappy Taxi Workers Alliance, barely has a pot to piss in? Drivers are lobbying for HB 1914, which would let them get workers' comp. Currently, they're eligible for precisely squat, despite a government report that found cabbies are 60 times more likely to be murdered on the job than other workers.

The TWA, I should mention, supports the TWU — and hey, nothing wrong with union solidarity. But there's benefits, and then there's benefits.

Isaiah Thompson did not mention casinos once this week. Thank him at isaiah.thompson@citypaper.net.

Comments

Hey Isaiah

Thanks for this article and bringing attention to the very real and important struggle of the TWA. They are in a hard battle to win some basic worker protections and we should all do everything we can to help make that happen.

That said, I do not think it is a correct analysis to use the TWA's fight to undercut the important fight that TWU is working for. We need people to be able to work 40 hours a week and making a living and bring up their families in relative security. TWU, and their contract, is important to us all because we must protect these precious middle class jobs and they become a compass point for drivers in TWA to strive for. We do not, on the other hand, do the drivers or transit workers a favor by saying well cabbies don't get it so bus drivers should not as well, because the real problem is the concentration of wealth in a very small percentage of the population not the small struggling transit workers that represent this cities dwindling middle class.
by Todd Wolfson on November 8th 2009 12:20 PM

I like to echo Todd's remarks on how this article comes across. This recession started with the flatlining of workers' wages across the board. The middle class keeps dwindling and we are headed for a two class economy. TWA is standing in solidarity with Local 234 for these reasons. Let us be clear, this struggle is bigger than both TWU and TWA, it's about working people everyplace given due worth for their labor. Especially when we look on the other side of the table and the enormous wealth that has been accumulated.
by Ron Blount on November 8th 2009 1:43 PM

Whatever TWU settles for will establish a standard for union and non-union members alike. While I don't like some of the inconveniences it causes I recognize the importance of what they are doing. I hope that all working people, especially union members, will come out and support TWU.
by Steve Chervenka on November 8th 2009 10:17 PM



Also In This Week's News Section

No Exceptions
by Julia Harte

Icepack
by A.D. Amorosi

A Million Stories
by Jeffrey C. Billman and Julia Harte

Sports:
Loser Gets Jersey
by E. James Beale

The Bell Curve
 
 
ADVERTISEMENT